Linde 5231 vs Crown SP1500: Which Turret Truck is Best?
Interested in investing in a turret truck but unsure of which one is the wisest investment?
Look no further than this article where we break down the TOP 2 performing turret trucks on the market in 2024: the Linde 5231 and Crown SP1500.
These powerhouse machines are designed to maximize efficiency and productivity in narrow-aisle environments. But which one is the best purchase for your business? Let’s dive into the basics, as well as the specs and features to help you make an informed decision.
What is a Turret Truck and are They Worth the High Price Tag?
What it is: A turret truck, also referred to as a VNA (Very Narrow Aisle) truck, is best designed to operate effectively and efficiently in very narrow aisles and spaces with limited space for maneuvering. Ideal for high-density warehouses and distribution centers, these battery-operated machines utilize electric engines, batteries, and operator compartments to efficiently counterbalance heavy loads.
Why some are so expensive: The higher price tag of the Linde 5231 and Crown SP 1500 turret trucks compared to some Very Narrow Aisle (VNA) trucks stems from their distinct capabilities. Unlike standard VNA trucks designed for lighter loads in narrower aisles, these turret trucks boast several features that elevate their performance for heavy-duty tasks. These include larger lift capacities, potentially faster lifting and travel speeds, and robust designs for handling significant loads at greater heights. Additionally, the Linde 5231 incorporates advanced safety features like the Linde Safety System (LSS) that contribute to its premium price point. While a standard VNA truck might suffice for basic pallet movement in tight spaces, for operations demanding power, speed, and safety when working with heavier stock, the additional expense of a turret truck like the SP 1500 or 5231 translates to increased efficiency and productivity.
Head-to-Head Comparison
| Feature | Linde 5231 | Crown SP1500 |
| Price Range | $80,000 – $100,000 | $75,000 – $95,000 |
| Max Battery Size | 80V | 48V |
| Load Capacity | 3,500 lbs | 3,000 lbs |
| Max Lift Height | 50 ft | 42 ft |
| Max Lift Speed – Unloaded | 130 (fpm) | 120 (fpm) |
| Max Lift Speed – Loaded | 118 (fpm) | 115 (fpm) |
| Max Travel Speed – Unloaded | Up to 10 mph (unloaded) | Up to 8 mph (unloaded) |
| Max Travel Speed – Loaded | Up to 7 mph (unloaded) | Up to 9 mph (unloaded) |
Now that we’ve laid out the basics, let’s explore the key differences that could make or break your decision.
Balancing Cost and Value: Crown Turret Trucks Has the Edge
When it comes to your bottom line, every dollar counts. The Crown SP1500 edges out the Linde 5231 in terms of initial cost, with a price range that’s about $5,000 lower. However, don’t let the price tag be your only deciding factor. Consider the long-term value and potential return on investment that each model offers.
Battery Size: Why Voltage Matters
While both the Crown SP 1500 and Linde 5231 likely utilize 48V batteries, it’s important to note that some turret trucks, particularly those designed for heavy-duty applications, are equipped with 80V batteries. This becomes especially relevant when considering the capabilities of the Linde 5231. The 80V system offers a significant power boost. This translates to stronger acceleration, faster lifting speeds, and the ability to handle steeper inclines – all crucial for maximizing productivity in demanding environments, especially when compared to the 48V system commonly found in the Crown SP 1500. Additionally, 80V batteries can potentially deliver more runtime on a single charge, minimizing downtime for battery swaps and keeping the Linde 5231 working longer during busy shifts. If these factors align with your warehouse needs, the 5231’s compatibility with a larger battery system could be a deciding factor when weighed against the 48V system typically found in the Crown SP 1500.
Lifting the Bar: Load Capacity and Lift Height
Both trucks offer an impressive 3,000 lb load capacity, ensuring they can handle most warehouse tasks with ease. However, the Crown SP1500 reaches two feet higher, maxing out at 42 feet compared to the Linde 5231’s 40-foot reach. Those extra two feet could make a significant difference in high-bay warehouses, plus support high-racking that saves space and costs for your operation.
Safety First: Advanced Features for Peace of Mind
Both manufacturers prioritize operator safety with cutting-edge features. The Linde 5231 boasts an advanced stability control system, while the Crown SP1500 offers innovative operator assistance technology. These safety features not only protect your employees but also help prevent costly accidents and downtime.
A notable safety feature found on the 5231 is the Linde Aisle Safety Assistant (ASA),which greatly increases narrow aisle trucks adaptability in warehouse conditions, minimizing collision risks and potential damage to goods and infrastructure.
The Extra Mile: Additional Features to Consider
- Energy Efficiency: Both models utilize electric power systems, promoting a greener warehouse environment.
- Ergonomics: Compare the operator compartments for comfort during long shifts.
- Maintenance: Look into the ease of servicing and availability of parts for each model.
- Warranty: Check the coverage and duration offered by both manufacturers.
Total Warehouse offers its clients fully comprehensive and customizable servicing and warranty packages because we understand that no operation can afford downed equipment.
Unlike our competitors, we fully invest in service support with over 200+ factory-certified technicians, GPS, wireless service technology, and customer response centers across the entire West Coast. Our highly trained service department outperforms the rest as we provide fast and expert repairs, service, maintenance for a wide range of forklifts, pallet jacks, & order pickers. Our goal is to maximize the value of your investment and minimize your total cost of ownership.
Don’t just purchase a turret truck from anyone, Partner with Us and Optimize Your Investment, Productivity, and TCO!
Our Final Thoughts?
Both the Linde 5231 and Crown SP1500 are exceptional turret trucks, however, the 5231 edges out its competition with superior lifting capacity, lifting height and speed, making it the best choice for businesses looking to get the most band for their buck.
Though the Linde 5231 cost more upfront, when compared to the Crown SP1500, it’s important to note that in my experience, Linde’s turret truck does not disappoint and is well worth the impressive price tag long term.
Total Warehouse has crushed the numbers for you and simply put, the Linde 5231 will pay you back in full, and then some in as little as 5 years after purchase! For more information, on the cost benefits of investing in a 5231 turret truck, you can read our case study linked here.
Total Warehouse are proud dealers for Linde Material Handling. We’ve helped countless businesses across the United States achieve lower maintenance, reduced costs, increased worker satisfaction, and increased economic
